
“I believe there is nothing more thrilling than eye contact while speaking.”
Her
words echoed through me. So many images. Images of time past and of
things that are yet to happen. Eyes that have haunted me for almost as
long as I can remember. And eyes that have left me cold, forlorn.
“Do you believe in love at first sight?” she asked me.
“No, I believe in love at second sight,” I answered.
“What do you mean?”
“When you really see someone for the first time.”
Can
you know someone for hours, days, months, years... and then one day
fall hopelessly in love with them, simply because of a momentary glance.
What has changed? Is it the light, the angle, a lingering smile - how
all these things come together for one perfect captivating moment? A moment
that passes, but leaves the image engraved in your mind.
I
am a people watcher. Perhaps this is to make up for my lack of social
skills. Or simply because of my curiosity - this obsession to unveil
the mysteries that lie beneath the surface. I sit back and observe, often
capturing the nuances that most people miss. Those subtle unconscious
gestures of people trying too hard to be accepted, when in reality they
simply want to be recognized for who they are. Witnessing their
vulnerability, vulnerability which they seek to hide, yet shows in their
eyes.
We
live in a society where we are told not to make eye contact. “There are
a lot of crazies out there.” On the subway it is not only - “Mind the
gap,” but also “Look away”. As if we must put our humanity on hold,
until we are once again in a safe room.
“I believe there is nothing more thrilling than eye contact while speaking,” she told me again, undeterred.
In
my so-called formative years, I closed myself off almost completely,
seeking to conquer my emotions, in a battle against bouts of depression.
I soon discovered that I could conquer my emotions, but not master
them, as they were pushed so far back that they were no longer
accessible. “You don’t feel anything,” Arlene said to me, crying, yet
another girl breaking up with me.
Until
a late winter evening. Not yet twenty and already convinced that I
would never really touch, nor be touched. I had seen her first when she
entered the party. Just another face. Then heard her arguing her
feminist views. Still, just another voice in the crowd. And then,
sitting with my back against the wall, I felt her. She sat on the
opposite side of the room, staring at me. Our eyes met and she
penetrated me, like no one had ever done before. I was captivated, lost.
All of my intricate defenses crumbling in a moment.
I
can still see her staring at me, into me. Feel the thrill. I need not
even close my eyes to experience this again. Even though we haven’t seen
each other for more years than I can remember.
“We don’t need to be physically with someone, to look into their eyes,” I said.
“You must have a very good imagination then,” she said. “Or is it memory?”
“Sometimes it's imagination. Sometimes it's memory. Sometimes it is something else.”
“What is left?” she asked.
“Have you ever looked at a profile picture on facebook and seen much more than what was there?”
“I don’t understand,” she said, “A picture is just a picture.”
“Confucius said that a picture is a poem without words."
“Do you think he was talking about facebook?”
“And Ernst Haas,” I pressed on, “wrote that each of us on earth is but a mosaic of a picture we will never see.”
She hesitated then.
“Yes, I like that,” she said finally.
“Do you believe we can look through eyes of paper and see into the soul?” I asked.
“I
believe some people do. I have been in cultures where the taking of
pictures is forbidden. They believe that you are trying to steal their
soul.”
“But what do you think?” I persisted.
“If it were my picture, I think it would be too dangerous.
“Why?”
"Because
you may fall in love with my picture. And then you will have a part of
me which is frozen in time. And I am not that person. I am different,
from moment to moment. You must let me change. Please, do not make me
stand still."
I
remembered the character, then, in my novel. The character, Guy, that
Michael created to seduce his wife in the desperate effort to bring
intimacy back into his marriage. There was a point when she needed
something to reassure her that Guy was real. So Michael, after much
searching through the Internet, found a man whose eyes he was sure Julia
would fall in love with. And Guy became real, not only for Julia, but
for Michael also.
“Look into my eyes, so that I know I am real.”

“Where are you from?” is a question I was often asked in Scotland.
How do I answer that?
Canada?
Israel? Does it really matter what I choose? For so long, my only
travelling was short visits to Canada and back, where both Canada and
Israel stake their claim to who I am.
But here, in Scotland, I was in neutral territory.
“Israel.”
Canada
would have been the simpler choice. Few people have reason to take any
interest if you say you are from Canada. Even less reason to throw
stones. When was the last time Canada really pissed somebody off?
But to claim to be from Canada would be to deny so much of what I have become.
“I live in the desert,” I added.
That
was a nice finishing touch, providing me with added immunity. For some
reason, people living in deserts appear to be beyond borders. Just ask
Israelis who ask to have their passports stamped when they make their
way south of Beer Sheva.
“You speak English really well.”
“I’m originally from Canada.”
“Ah.”
That tended to conveniently confuse the issue. No talk about politics tonight.
Scots,
as we all know, are not new to questions of identity. They have had no
reigning monarch for 300 years, are no longer considered an independent
country but rather a part of The United Kingdom, and their “Pound
Scots” was abruptly abolished in 1707 and replaced by Scottish money
similar in denomination and value to the English bank notes, although
the Scottish notes are not of legal tender.
“You
see that?” I was asked by one B&B owner, as a Scottish ten pound
note was flashed in front of me. “We print our own money now. And it is
as good as any other. But there are always a few bastards down south who
refuse to take them. They will get their comeuppance.”
I have always wondered why many Scots keep old swords hanging on their walls, swords which they also keep well sharpened.
On
our last day in Edinburgh, I saw a shirt that read - “I’m for Scotland,
or for anybody playing against England.” That pretty well says it all,
doesn’t it.
But
the Scots have their own way in getting in the last word. Long ago they
discovered that if you take anything that still resembles a castle,
palace, or formidable edifice - hang up a few explanations in the
various rooms as to their historical importance, you can cash in for
about 6 pounds a head. And, if you can display the pivotal role that
this edifice once played in the struggle against English suppression of
rightful Scottish national aspirations, you can get much more than that.
And for a few rousing stories of time past, you can even get 4 quid a
head for a few ruins of crumbling walls and stairs leading nowhere.
Factor into this that many of the tourists are from England down south and ...
need I say more?
Of
course, the complexity of Scottish identity is not all about the
English suppression. Other factors also need to be taken into account.
The Picts, for instance. “Whatever happened to the Picts?” All that
appears left are inscriptions on stones.
And then there are the clans. We can never forget the clans.
I
envy the Scots their surnames. My last name - “Lloyd” - is of Welsh
origin. But having a Welsh name isn’t anywhere as much fun as having a
name of one of the clans. With a name like “Montgomery”, you get your
own coat of arms (family crest), and can purchase cups, saucers, shirts,
keyrings, kilts.... you name it ... all with your coat of arms proudly
displayed. And if you look hard enough, you’ll find proof that you are
the next legal heir to the throne of Scotland, if the throne were ever
to return. So much rich historical tradition surrounding your surname
and the only question I ever get about my Welsh surname is whether I
have any connection to the bank. But don’t get me wrong, I am proud of
my Welsh ancestry. And don’t even get me started on how we Welsh were
exploited by the English.

Sixteen years ago, I travelled through the United Kingdom for two weeks with my youngest son, Noam. This summer, I travelled with my elder son, Edan, for close to three weeks throughout Scotland. Many things were different in the space of 16 years, but perhaps the greatest difference of all was the ready presence of Wi-Fi.
Now I know that some of you may romanticize the days when there was no such thing as “instant communication” no matter where you were in the world. Backpacking in Europe in the 70’s, letting loved ones know that you will be in a certain city at some time in the future and when you arrive there you head for the “post restante” section of the local post office to find a letter waiting for you. Yes, that thing made out of paper with the musty smell. This way you managed to communicate with back home about once a month. Of course, by the time the letters were read, the events described belonged more to “history” than to “current events”.
But now you can exchange countless emails per day, text chat or even Skype with video. And all this on something as small as a smartphone or iPod. Not to mention taking pictures with your smartphone or iPod and immediately uploading them to your facebook profile for all to see. And all this for free. Is this a good thing? I think so, but then you may consider me an Internet junkie.
When leaving for Scotland, I wondered how much Wi-Fi access we would have. I soon discovered that almost all Bed and Breakfasts have Wi-Fi. Some worked better than others, but you were always assured of some sort of connection. We also discovered that Wi-Fi was available in many coffee and lunch spots along the way, even in the local coffee shop of a small town in a remote section of the Cairngorms National Park. Edan and I got into a routine whenever we “landed” for a coffee or lunch break: order coffee/food, bathroom, and out came his smartphone and my iPod and it was time to check mail and upload that last picture.
And then we got to Edinburgh, the tourist hub of Scotland. A magical city, with plenty to see, not to mention the unique pubs. We spent the last two days of our trip there.
The first day we settled into a pub for a late lunch after walking through a surprisingly warm day (the sun was actually out most of the time).
“Do you have Wi-Fi, we asked?”
“No, sorry. Not yet. We will soon.”
So, there we were, waiting for our food and sipping a pint, while fidgeting, our fingers tapping nervously on the table, not able to text, chat, or upload.
Now, don’t get me wrong - we are not that obsessed. We can get through one meal without wi-fi access. We simply put this down to our wandering in by chance to a pub that didn’t have wi-fi - a surprise occurrence after finding it in the most remote locations.
But it was later in the day, after a short rest at the B&B, when we made for another pub to watch the EuroCup that we began to suspect a pattern.
“Do you have Wi-Fi?”
“No, sorry. Not yet. We will soon.”
The fidgeting increased, but once the football game started, it eased up.
We decided the next day that we wouldn’t order a pint until we found a pub with wi-fi. Well, none was to be found. “No, sorry. Not yet, we will soon.” We did find a sort of underground connection at the Caffe Nero on the Royal Mile. It was called something like “Free Scotland”. I wasn’t sure whether this meant the wi-fi connection was free, or whether it was a part of an intricate plan to reclaim Scotland’s independence.
“Hey, they have an Internet connection here,” I announced happily to Edan.
“Shhh...” came from a nearby table, as its inhabitant looked around nervously. I understood then that there were some things that you didn’t talk about in public - at least not in the streets of Edinburgh. Was this a part of a cartel? Were the drinking and eating places of Edinburgh joining together to ensure that they didn’t need to offer wi-fi, and wouldn’t need to worry that the competition did?
Or is there a message here? A reason why a city like Edinburgh would shun offering Wi-Fi when it was present almost everywhere else - other than the evident cost of such free offerings? Did it have something to do with the flavour of the city? Is Edinburgh a modern day Brigadoon, wanting to let time flow by and remain changeless?
Somehow I think that if I visit Edinburgh in another 16 years time, they still won’t have wi-fi.
“No, sorry. Not yet. We will soon.”

There are still books out there. Many, many books. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised. Books have been here for... well, not forever, but for a very long time. More than I can remember, at least, but that’s not saying much.
The thing is: the book is quite a clever concept. A bundle of knowledge, strapped together by pieces of leather... well, once by leather... But it is the concept of the book which matters, whether in hard cover or in soft cover.
“What about an electronic cover?”
“How can something electronic be a cover? It is virtual.”
“Therefore it does not exist?”
“Yes, I mean no. I mean, it must exist if we can still read its pages.”
“Yes?”
“But that doesn’t make it a book.”
“Not even an electronic book?”
“Call me a romantic. I still like the smell of leather... Well, something to hold in my hands.”
“I hold my Kindle in my hands. Can even hold it and turn the pages with the same hand.”
*insert awkward pause
“Anyhow, I liked things the way they were.”
“Writing on stone, you mean.”
“Now let’s not go to extremes.”
“Me go to extremes!”
The thing is, electronic books, electronic information of any type, excites me. No, it is not a fetish. I simply like access to anything, anywhere, at any time. Many of you will claim that I have become a part of the “me now” generation which demands immediate satisfaction, and can do with nothing less. But I will have nothing to do with this.
I have always had a fascination for books. I would travel with my parents and suddenly disappear. They knew then to search for the nearest bookstore. Opening a book was an exploration, an exploration into a parallel universe from whence I emerged changed, even if only in a small way. But so much has happened since. It used to be that a teacher could stand up at the front of a one room schoolhouse and teach students all there was needed to know. A set of encyclopedias could contain all of the information of both the modern and ancient worlds. Dictionaries could contain an accurate list of vocabulary and not need to be updated for decades. But then came the information explosion. Books became out of date almost before they were published. A wise teacher soon realized that s/he could no longer be a valid source of information but should rather serve as “facilitator”, in leading students to search, find and properly evaluate information. Huge conglomerations which once controlled the access to knowledge, have now lost their control over us. And writers can now easily turn out their novels on a computer, and even go way of self-publishing rather than suffer years of rejection at the hands of literary agents and publishers who are becoming less and less willing to take chances in a market whose bottom is falling out.
When I finally got my own novel published, I had no idea what was waiting for me in the literary world. Bookstores, however big, can not even represent a fraction of what is out there. Many of you will claim that most of the books published today are probably not even worth printing. But the thing is, there are many good books out there which would have never gotten published otherwise. And I, personally, take this to be the decisive factor: not the surplus of what we consider unworthy, but rather the absence of what should be there.
But what I have found to be even more compounding is how social networks offer an interactive platform in which readers and writers come together - where readers and writers no longer sit in worlds clearly separate, but are now accountable to each other. Writing has become a social experience in ways never conceived of before.
And I realize now that being a writer not only means that I should write books, but that I also should bring something back to books and writers that I read. This is why I began my own book review blog - “The Virtual Muser eBook Review”. And I must say that I am learning as much from this experience as I am from my own writing.
Books are here to stay. Maybe not in the way that you would expect or hope them to. But they have been here forever, at least in the human experience. Whether they were written in stone, or told and passed down from generation to generation. Think of it: the concept has never changed. And what about the need?
You might say, then - why even sell books? Why not just put them up there for anybody to download? Isn’t the message the thing that is important? You may or may not be surprised to hear that more and more writers are doing exactly this. Is this the beginning of a serious trend? We will wait and find out.

People annoy me. What can I say. I don’t even remember when it started. I have a vague memory of the doctor slapping me when I came out of my mother’s womb...
Not all people annoy me. Or at least, not all of the people all of the time.
“You can be very annoying,” you say.
“Yes,” I answer. “What is your point, exactly?
People, by themselves, are not always annoying enough to reach my radar. It usually takes an extension of themselves: their pet dog or brood of children - to really get under my skin. You see, most people believe that they are god’s gift to mankind. And, just in case no one has gotten the point, they send out their dogs and children to get into the face of anybody who might otherwise ignore them. You’ve been there: kids running rampant through the aisles in the supermarket, screaming at the top of their lungs when something is refused - dogs barking in the middle of the night while their owners sleep peacefully and leave the rest of us to toss and turn in despair.
Now, I like animals. Actually like them much more than people. There is probably a name for that ( there is a name for everything these days). Maybe it is because both animals and I don’t talk much. Much more into observing. So, the other night, at 1:30 in the morning, I went out and picked up some stones on the way to confront the dog who was barking behind my house. Getting there, I found a dog tied up outside of a house. He saw me and wagged his tail with a huge dog smile, glad to welcome a human presence so late at night/early morning. What could I do, then? Throw a stone at him? So I left him to it and went back to bed, cursing the moron who should have never been allowed to have a dog, much like many parents who should have never been allowed to have children.
If you find this not to be politically correct, so far, I can only say that it is going to get worse. But in order to partially placate your delicate sense of fair play, I will no longer brand people as “annoying”. Rather, let’s just say that they are “socially challenged”.
Actually, I am just as socially challenged as anyone else, but I keep it to myself. Which most people consider annoying. You see, I can sit at a party, or dinner, or any other social event a whole night and say nothing. Most people will probably pass this off as my not being intelligent enough to take part in their riveting conversation. Other people attribute my silence to my not finding them, or their conversation, interesting. And this really pisses them off. You are supposed to mingle in social situations. And if you don’t have anything interesting to say, making a fool out of yourself is just as socially acceptable.
“What are you, socially autistic?” you ask.
“I have never thought about it in that way,” I answer. “But now that you mention it, the shoe fits.”
The irony of it all is that I am not a people person (if you haven’t already guessed), yet I have spent almost all of my adult life living in small communities (we are talking about less than a thousand souls - not counting the dogs). This brings me into more contact with people than I would have, say, in the city. The first community (14 years of my life) was a kibbutz. The second community (20+ years and counting) is a small community on the edge of the Zin Wadi. When we first came here, the community was much smaller, almost everyone knew each other, and there was a feeling of common purpose in living here. This has changed over the years. What was once a cohesive community has turned into social anarchy. We could blame this on how quickly the community has expanded, as more and more people build houses here. Or on the fact that many people build houses only to rent them out at obscene prices in order to make a windfall. But the main factor may be that many people have recognized this is a place where they, their children and their dogs can live as free spirits. What others might call - “running wild”. But hey, let’s not quibble over semantics.
I mean, how many places do you know where you can let your dog run loose terrorizing children and bark all night terrorizing aspiring sleepers, without any fear of being called into account. Yes, we do have a “residents committee” which has promised to work towards “enriching” our communal experience. And yes, like most good committees, they keep sending us newsletters telling us about how they are going to round up dogs on the loose and call their owners into account. For about ten years, we have seen these proclamations repeatedly. Haven’t seen them in a while though, probably because a dog chews them up, just as two dogs chewed up our Friday newspaper which was dropped off early morning by the paper boy. Did the dog owner offer to buy us a new newspaper? No, he simply cleaned the mess of torn fragments off of his OWN lawn.
“Bitter. You think I sound bitter? No, not at all. That is one of the advantages of being a socially autistic and cynical pessimist. You don’t hold high expectations.”
“The name of the small community where I am living now? I think I will keep this to myself. Otherwise, you’re so vain, you’ll probably think this blog is about you.
Vivian
Rakoff, in “Ideally Speaking” says: “Idealism in a way is a
manifestation of a generalized human desire to have a sense-making model
or paradigm of the world. There are those who just accept what is given
to them implicitly without it being explicit and there are those who
try to make it explicit and if they haven’t got a model, go looking for
it. We seem to need a sense-making system that takes away the sense of
frivolity in our existence because we have a real terror of
meaninglessness.”
The
major difference between myself, and the South African Jews interviewed
in the book who decided to emigrate to Israel in the end, is that they
came here for reasons of ideology. I came first and discovered the
ideology afterwards.
In
a way, I am somewhat envious of those who grew up in Jewish youth
movements, with a clear sense of their own identity, engaging in
intellectual discussions of burning issues. Jonathan Broomberg, in
“Ideally Speaking”, says: “My sense is that each person who was in the
movement in each generation has a different and quite unique relation to
that ideology. At one end of the spectrum were people whose involvement
was entirely a function of the group while at the other end you had
people for whom it ran very deep personally.”
The
reason for my lack of ideology, then, as a youth, might have been
because there was no group for me to be a part of. I grew up in a rather
sterile WASPish suburb of Toronto. My family didn’t have any marked
ethnic distinction. And although I read extensively - devouring the
theories of Freud, the teachings of different world religions, the
background to revolution and the philosophy of the ancient Greeks...
there was no one to intellectually share these ideas with. At a time
when the hippies were beginning to assemble in the streets of downtown
Toronto, preaching new world order from their makeshift community in
Yorkville, my peers in Scarborough were only concerned with the trivial
affairs of the day.
And
by the time that I was old enough to join the hippie movement, it was
already petering out. But two things stayed with me from all of their
proclamations for social renewal and a better world: one was the idea of
communal living and the other was the return to the land.
Meanwhile,
in South Africa, the Jewish youth there were also talking about
creating a better world, although their approach was quite different
from that of the “flower generation. In most Jewish youth movements,
the concept of Israel and the kibbutz were almost inseparable. Israel
was seen to hold the promise of “a light unto the nations”, and most saw
this to be best realized through the socialistic and utopian nature of
the kibbutz life style.
By
the time I heard about the kibbutz in my sheltered existence, the “real
terror of meaninglessness” had already led me to consider leaving Canada
in the search of something more. I heard about the kibbutz for the first
time from a friend of my sister’s, who was planning to go to a six
month ulpan on a kibbutz where you learn Hebrew half the day and work
the other half. Something seemed to click when she told me about this
and I felt that this was something I had to do. The irony was that she
never did go to Israel in the end, but rather went to work with the
native Indian community somewhere in Alberta, trying to right the wrongs
of discrimination in her own backyard. Which is somewhat similar to the
decision of many South African Jews not to emigrate to Israel but stay
in South Africa and fight against Apartheid.
So,
somehow I and many South Africans ended up in the same place. I had
never planned, though, to stay here. I came to see socialism in action,
and also learn Hebrew on the side. The ideology only really came
afterwards. There was a time when I believed I would spend the rest of
my life on the kibbutz. But that is when reality set in, both for me and for
many of the South Africans who had decided to settle on a kibbutz. We
gradually discovered the discrepancies between vision and reality;
between the idealization of human nature and human primal instinct. If
“Ideally Speaking” is any indication, most of the South African Jews who
came to live on a kibbutz have since left. Many have left Israel, also -
some going back to South Africa and others settling in other countries
around the globe. We came very close to leaving Israel when we left the
kibbutz, also. But in the end, we stayed, settling for isolation in the
desert. The main difference here between me and South Africans, was that
I only felt overly disillusioned with the kibbutz, feeling that it
didn’t live up to its ideals. Many South Africans had become
disillusioned with the country as a whole, feeling that they had been
misled during their years in the youth movements about what really to
expect. But my advantage, perhaps, was that I had first landed in Israel
without any expectations. No one had tried to plant a pretty picture in
my mind about Israel. Rather, at the kibbutz desk, when applying to
come to a kibbutz ulpan, they appeared more interested in dissuading me
from going.
You
might wonder why I have concentrated on comparing my own experience to
that of South African Jews. Why I would want to make such a comparison
at all. Or why I didn’t choose youth closer to home, such as North
American Jewish youth.
This
was inspired by a book I recently read and have quoted here: “Ideally Speaking”. Although the book is based on a series of interviews with a
wide cross-section of South African Jews - now living in South Africa,
Israel and abroad - I feel that much of what is expressed in the book is
relevant to all of us, and warmly recommend the book to all of you. I
first heard of the book from one of its two editors: Steve Hellman
(Lindsay Talmud is the other editor). I had never met a South African
before coming to Israel and Steve was one of the first South Africans
that I did meet. Not only that, but Steve played a significant part in
my life in the early eighties when I was just starting out as a new
teacher. In his role as coordinator of the English department at Kibbutz
Brenner Regional High School, where I began my teaching career, Steve
both welcomed me to the world of teaching and served as my mentor. And I
owe it to him for not only getting through those first few months as a
new teacher, but for also instilling in me the inspiration for
thinking outside of the box in my teaching and in creating authentic
teaching environments. Thirty years have passed since then and only now
have I really discovered the world that Steve came from. And I thank him
for what he gave me then, and what he has shared with me now.



Why do men have beards? There are a multitude of explanations, I’m sure. Freud must have devoted a chapter to it, somewhere. I can only speak for myself, and even then, I am on shaky ground.
I think I decided to “sprout” a beard as soon as I was able to grow one. Most likely, even before that - when facial hair was no more than an unpromising stubble. Was this in an effort to appear older? Or perhaps, I saw it as a stamp of my own individuality. I really can’t remember that far back. I only know that, except for a few years later in life, I had a beard in some shape or form.
By the time I could grow a beard, and had reached an age where I could grow my hair long, the hippies had pretty well run out of steam - many of them leaving behind their nomadic, power of love life style, to open stylish boutiques where money became their new object of concern. We were into the seventies, the sixties were but a memory, but either no one had told me that the flower generation was over, or I didn’t care. With my long hair and beard, I set out for an Israeli commune, looking for a life where people lived together in harmony and social bliss.
It would be interesting to measure my induction into the socialistic life style of the kibbutz against the length of my beard. When I arrived on the kibbutz, one might say that my beard was “bushy”. Yet still under control. I had spent two months before that working in a small hotel on Rue Pigalle in Paris - what was known as the red light district. The characters that I met during those two months could have provided the inspiration for a compelling thriller. They took one look at this young Canadian boy, who they called “Le petit Jesus”, and took me under their ward. They would take me out for a walk through Paris late at night and I knew that there was nothing to be scared of, as they were much scarier than anything we could possibly meet on the way. At the end of the two months, when I was supposed to go to Israel to join an ulpan, they did everything in their power (other than kidnapping me) to try and convince me to stay. I often wonder what would have happened if I had stayed. But more about that in a future blog entry, entitled “Life Choices”.
So when did my beard start getting out of control. One might say, just before my marriage. By then I looked like a character out of the “Lion King” - or The Lion King himself. I was still in an upward spiral, becoming more and more of an integral part of the kibbutz, filling many roles such as head of the Manpower and Education committees. We had our first child and he spent his first years sleeping in the children’s house. But then things began to change - the kibbutz began to change. The signs were there - had been for quite a while, I imagine. Even now, although I left the kibbutz for the same ideological reasons that brought me there, I am surprised at how quickly it all fell apart. Right up to privatization.
And these are the years where my beard got increasingly shorter. Soon, the overall bushy look was gone, although there was still a firm growth of beard there. A vote in the general assembly decided that children would now live at home. And, as I became more and more involved in the sensitive areas of the kibbutz - especially when I became the head of the Members Committee, I saw how big the cracks had become, and found it difficult to justify staying there any longer. And my beard could now be described as “neat” - something it hadn’t been since my early Canadian years.
It must have been a year or two after we left the kibbutz, moving down to live in the Negev, that I shaved off my beard altogether. Maybe this was my way of stating that I was starting something completely new. I needed something to signify the separation, something which was an intricate part of myself. I remember when Adva came home and saw this strange man in the house. She was quite excited at the time, at least for the first few minutes until she realized it was me. That is another good thing about having a beard. By shaving it off, you can feel that you made a significant change in your life. Even if it is only for a moment. But growing a beard is nowhere the same. As G. K. Chesterton once said: “You cannot grow a beard in a moment of passion.”
When it comes down to it, it is all skin deep - or should I say “hair deep”. Some people told me that being clean shaven made me look more distinguished, others - “younger’... but there were those - especially my sister and two childhood friends - who appeared to have a problem recognizing me in my new naked form. Not that they didn’t know who I was - but they had grown up knowing me only as a bearded wonder. And then this new person walked into their lives and he didn’t quite fit.
Probably the thing that convinced me to grow back a beard, albeit a small one, was that I could never get used to not being able to run my hand over my beard when in deep contemplation. There was no friction to help me think. Also, while staring at myself in the mirror, I was taken aback by the gaunt look. So, much to the chagrin of some people, I started to sprout facial hairs again.
And here I am, late in life, wondering whether to just shave it all off again. Is it now the need to look younger? Or simply a need for change? In my facebook status, I asked people to vote for what they like more: a bearded or beardless David. If I thought they would help me decide, I was mistaken, as the votes are split more or less down the middle.
Maybe I should listen to the wisdom of Jean Cocteau: “There is always a period when a man with a beard shaves it off. The period does not last. He returns headlong to his beard.”
There are those who experiment with having a beard, and those of us who experiment without having one.